The SEC desires disgraced VC Mike Rothenberg to cough up greater than $30 million

Almost three years in the past, TechCrunch reported on suspected fraud dedicated by Mike Rothenberg, a self-described “millennial enterprise capitalist” who’d made a reputation for himself not solely by eponymously branding his enterprise agency however for spending lavishly to woo startup founders, together with on Napa Valley wine excursions, at luxurious bins at Golden State Warriors video games and, most famously, internet hosting an annual “founder subject day” on the San Francisco Giants’ baseball stadium that later impressed a scene within the HBO present “Silicon Valley.”

The Securities & Change Fee had initially reached out to Rothenberg in June of 2016 and by final August, he’d been formally charged for misappropriating as much as $7 million of his buyers’ capital. He settled with the company with out making an request for forgiveness, and, as a part of the settlement, he stepped down from what was left of the agency and agreed to be barred from the brokerage and funding advisory enterprise with a proper to reapply after 5 years.

Now, comes the cash half. Following a forensic audit carried out in partnership with the accounting agency Deloitte, the SEC is looking for $18.Eight million in disgorgement penalties from Rothenberg, and an extra $9 million civil penalty. The SEC can be asking that Rothenberg be compelled to pay pre-judgment curiosity of $3,663,323.47.

The way it arrived at that math: Based on a brand new lawsuit filed on Wednesday, the SEC argues that Rothenberg raised a internet quantity of roughly $45.9 million throughout six enterprise funds from at the least 200 buyers, however that he took “charges” on their capital that far exceeded what his agency was entitled to through the lifetime of these funds, masking up these “misdeeds” by “modifying accounting entries to make his misappropriation appear to be investments, getting into into undisclosed transactions to paper over diverted cash, and shuffling investments from one [f]und to a different to hide prior diversions.”

In the end, it says, Deloitte’s examination demonstrated that Rothenberg misappropriated $18.Eight million that rightfully belong to Rothenberg Ventures, $3.Eight million of which was transferred to Rothenberg personally; $8.Eight million of which was used to fund different entities beneath his management (together with a automobile racing workforce and a digital actuality studio); and $5.7 of which was used to pay the agency’s bills “over and above” the administration and administrative charges it was entitled to per its administration agreements.

We reached out to Rothenberg this morning. He has not but responded to our request to debate the event.

It sounds from the submitting like he gained’t have a lot wiggle room. Based on the SEC’s swimsuit, the “Rothenberg Judgment” agreed upon final summer season left financial reduction to be determined by a courtroom’s judgment, one which “supplies that Rothenberg accepts the info alleged within the grievance as true, and doesn’t contest his legal responsibility for the violations alleged, for the needs of this movement and at any listening to on this movement.”

Within the meantime, the lawsuit comprises fascinating nuggets, together with an alleged maneuver through which Rothenberg raised $1.Three million to spend money on the sport engine firm Unity however by no means truly purchased shares within the firm, as a substitute diverting the capital to different entities. (He finally paid again $1 million to 1 investor who repeatedly requested for the cash again, however not the opposite $300,000.)

Rothenberg additionally offered a stake within the stock-trading agency Robinhood for $5.four million, says the SEC, however somewhat than funnel any proceeds to buyers, he once more directed the cash elsewhere, together with, evidently, to pay for a luxurious suite throughout Golden State Warriors video games for which he shelled out $136,000.

In a transfer that one Rothenberg investor finds notably galling, the SEC claims that Rothenberg then circled and rented that field by an on-line market that allows folks to purchase and promote suites at varied sports activities and leisure venues, receiving at the least $56,000 from the follow.

In an obvious effort to maintain up appearances, Rothenberg additionally gave $30,000 to the Stanford College Athletics Division (he attended Stanford as an undergrad) and spent hundreds of {dollars} on ballet tickets final yr and early this yr, says the SEC’s submitting.

No matter what occurs subsequent, one small victor within the SEC’s detailed findings is Silicon Valley Financial institution, a sprawling enterprise that has aggressively courted the tech trade since its 1983 founding. Final yr, on the similar time that Rothenberg was agreeing to be barred from the trade, he made a continued present of his innocence by submitting swimsuit towards SVB to “vindicate the pursuits of its funds and buyers,” the agency stated in an announcement on the time.

The implication was that SVB was at fault for a few of Rothenberg’s woes as a result of it had not correctly wired cash to the proper accounts, however the SEC says that SVB was defrauded, offering Rothenberg a $four million line of credit score after being offered with fabricated paperwork.

A loser — aside from Rothenberg and the many individuals who now really feel cheated by him — is Harvard Enterprise Faculty. The rationale: it used Rothenberg Ventures as a case examine for college students after Rothenberg graduated from this system. As we’ve reported beforehand, that case examine — funded by HBS earlier than any trace of hassle on the agency had surfaced  — was co-authored by two professors who had a “vital monetary curiosity in Rothenberg Ventures,” as acknowledged prominently in a curriculum footnote.

Presumably, these ties gave confidence to at the least a few of the buyers in Silicon Valley and elsewhere who later offered Rothenberg with cash to speculate on their behalf.

You’ll be able to learn the SEC’s 20-page movement for disgorgement and penalties beneath, together with the 48-page report assembled by Deloitte’s forensic accounting companion, Gerry Fujimoto.

SEC vs. Mike Rothenberg by TechCrunch on Scribd

Forensic report re Mike Rothenberg/Rothenberg Ventures by TechCrunch on Scribd

Extra reporting by TechCrunch’s Sarah Perez.

Above: Rothenberg Ventures throughout higher days.

0 Comment

Leave a comment